Why Ukrainians and Russians are not one people, and why Russians are not Ukraine’s indigenous people
Ukraine Crisis Media Center, 2 July, 2021
The persistent Russian imperial myth that Ukrainians and Russians constitute a single, indivisible nation is fundamentally false, and ethnic Russians do not meet the historical or legal criteria to be classified as an indigenous group within Ukraine. This article systematically deconstructs the Kremlin’s propagandistic narratives by highlighting the distinct ethnogenesis, linguistic development, and political traditions that historically separate the two nations. The text exposes how Moscow manipulates history and terminology to deny Ukraine’s distinct national identity and justify its aggressive territorial claims.
The ideological concept portraying Ukrainians and Russians as “fraternal peoples” is a manipulative imperial construct designed to enforce a false sense of historical kinship and justify Moscow’s dominance. This article deconstructs the popular myth of “brotherly nations”, tracing its origins to Soviet and Russian imperial propaganda aimed at erasing Ukraine’s distinct cultural and political identity. This alleged brotherhood has always been strictly hierarchical, positioning Russia as the older sibling entitled to dictate the fate of the younger Ukrainian counterpart. By examining the deep linguistic, cultural, and historical differences between the two societies, the text illustrates why the “fraternity” narrative contradicts the reality. The article also explains how this artificial narrative is actively exploited by the Kremlin to legitimize its ongoing aggression and deny Ukraine its right to true independence.
Where does the idea that Russians and Ukrainians are one people come from?
Hypotheses, 16 September, 2024
The ideological framework asserting that Russians and Ukrainians constitute a unified ethnos is not a historical reality, but rather a deliberately constructed narrative originating from Russian imperial historiography. This article traces the genealogical roots of the “All-Russian nation” concept, examining how tsarist and later Soviet intellectuals manufactured this myth to consolidate territorial control and assimilate distinct Slavic populations. By exploring the political motivations behind this historical revisionism, the author reveals how the idea of a shared identity was systematically weaponized to suppress Ukrainian language, culture, and early aspirations for statehood. The analysis provides essential context for understanding how these deeply entrenched imperial myths were created and how they continue to fuel today’s Russian geopolitical aggression against Ukraine.
Ukrainians and Russians are not one people – but perhaps not for the reason you think
PONARS Eurasia, 21 April, 2023
The profound divergence between Ukrainians and Russians is rooted not merely in ancient ethno-linguistic differences, but primarily in their contrasting modern political trajectories and divergent civic nation-building experiences over recent decades. This publication challenges the traditional focus on primordial history, arguing instead that the distinct identities of the two societies have been solidified by their radically different approaches to state-society relations, democracy, and governance since the collapse of the Soviet Union. The author demonstrates that, while the Kremlin obsesses over medieval origins to justify its imperial claims, a modern, consolidated Ukrainian civic identity has rapidly emerged, driven by a strong desire for democratic self-determination. The ongoing Russian aggression has only accelerated this irreversible separation, forging a unified Ukrainian nation that firmly rejects Moscow’s authoritarianism.
Why is Ukraine not Russia? | What propaganda is silent about (with English captions)
Zerkalo, 5 May, 2023
YouTube video: 07:50 min
Russian state propaganda intentionally suppresses the deep historical, political, and cultural realities that have shaped Ukraine as a distinct, independent nation entirely separate from Russia. This video dismantles the Kremlin’s mythological narratives by outlining the divergent evolutionary paths of the two societies over the centuries. Ukraine has long-standing traditions of horizontal self-governance, civic engagement, and democratic values, contrasting them directly with Russia’s historical inclination toward autocracy and centralized power. By exposing the factual context that Russian state media deliberately omits, the video clarifies the root causes of Ukrainians’ fierce defence of its sovereignty. The short documentary provides a concise, fact-based refutation of the imperial falsehoods used by Moscow to justify its ongoing military aggression.
Ukraine is not Russia: How different laws divided Ukrainian and Russian societies
TripMustGoOn, 20 January, 2023
YouTube video: 22:20 min
The difference between Ukraine and Russia is demonstrated not only by language, culture and religion, but also by political traditions. Democratic traditions of self-government and civic society have been familiar to Ukrainians for centuries. Ukrainian lands have a long history of close contacts with the western Christian countries of Europe, where the types of relations between the state and the society were essentially different from the autocracy and absolutism established in the Moscow lands. This video describes how the two territories were run, how Ukrainian cities were ruled, how democracy was maintained by Cossacks, and what Moscow tsars did to suppress Ukrainians’ aspirations to democracy. Although the democratic traditions, historically inherent in Ukraine, were successfully buried under the imperial oppression of Russia, they have not been eradicated from Ukrainians’ national mentality.
What makes Ukrainians different from Russians: Ukrainian democracy vs Moscow authoritarianism
TripMustGoOn, 4 April, 2023
YouTube video: 21:04 min
The fundamental difference between Ukrainians and Russians is rooted in their radically divergent historical political cultures: Ukraine’s centuries-old tradition of grassroots democracy versus Moscow’s enduring legacy of autocracy. The video explores the evolution of these contrasting societal norms, showing how Ukrainian lands developed civic institutions, decentralized power structures, and a strong sense of individualism through the country’s European past and the Cossack era. Conversely, the Russian state was built on absolute centralization, unquestioning obedience, and the systemic suppression of civil liberties.
The history of the Ukrainian army: the desire for freedom against forced army service
TripMustGoOn, 11 July, 2023
YouTube video: 19:19 min
The historical evolution of the Ukrainian military demonstrates a profound, centuries-old tradition of voluntary service and democratic organization that contrasts sharply with the Russian model of forced conscription and absolute subjugation. This video traces the divergent paths of armed forces in Ukraine and Russia from the era of Kyivan Rus’ through the Lithuanian-Polish period and the Cossack epoch. The video highlights how Ukrainian military formations, particularly the Zaporizhian Cossacks, were built upon principles of grassroots democracy, elected leadership, and a deep-seated desire for personal freedom. In contrast, the Muscovite and later Russian imperial armies relied on rigid feudal hierarchies, violent coercion, and the enslavement of their own soldiers.

