This is a video story of Ukraine’s long struggle for national identity under Russian imperial rule. After the defeat of Hetman Ivan Mazepa in 1709, the Russian Empire abolished the Cossack Hetmanate, destroyed Ukrainian autonomy, and reintroduced serfdom. Despite this, Ukrainian identity survived and gradually evolved into a national revival influenced by European Romanticism and revolutionary ideas. From the late 18th century, Ukrainian nobles and intellectuals promoted language, culture, and historical awareness, while some, like Vasyl Kapnist, even sought foreign support for independence. In the 19th century, secret organizations such as the Brotherhood of Saints Cyril and Methodius, including Shevchenko, Kostomarov, and Kulish, advanced ideas of freedom and equality. Later, cultural movements like the Hromadas strengthened national consciousness through education and literature. By the late 19th century, these efforts developed into political organizations, laying the foundation for Ukraine’s modern liberation movement.


The Cyril and Methodius Brotherhood (Kyrylo-Methodiivske Bratstvo) was a secret society founded in Kyiv in late 1845 – early 1846 by Mykola Kostomarov. The group aimed to build a new social order based on Christian values of justice, freedom, equality, and brotherhood. Its main goals included abolishing serfdom, giving equal rights to all people, developing national languages and cultures for all Slavic nations, spreading education among ordinary people, and creating a federation of Slavic states with Ukraine playing a leading role and Kyiv as its capital. Key members included Taras Shevchenko, Panteleimon Kulish, Mykola Hulak, and Vasyl Bilozersky. The society was discovered and broken up by Russian authorities in March 1847. Its members were arrested, investigated, and punished with exile or imprisonment. Despite its short existence, the Brotherhood had a strong influence on the later Ukrainian national movement.


Johannes Remy’s article outlines the Russian Empire’s late-19th-century attempts to eradicate Ukrainian identity via the Valuev Circular and Ems Ukaz, which banned Ukrainian-language publishing and education. Despite this severe cultural repression, Ukrainian activists (Ukrainophiles) utilized legal loopholes, Aesopian language, and trans-border smuggling networks from Galicia to maintain a resilient underground, ensuring the survival and evolution of their language and national movement. Even when the Valuev Circular of 1863 severely choked off literary publication, grassroots figures pushed ahead by standardizing grammar in underground print networks. This relentless localized push ultimately crippled Russia’s assimilation goals and ensured that a separate Ukrainian high culture successfully crystallized by the century’s end.


The Russian Empire failed to assimilate Ukrainians in the 19th century despite systematic efforts to destroy their identity. After eliminating Cossack autonomy, imperial authorities imposed centralized rule and promoted the idea of a unified Russian nation, even appropriating the legacy of Kyivan Rus to legitimize domination. However, assimilation policies were undermined by deep-rooted social, cultural, and economic differences between Ukrainians and Russians. The Ukrainian peasantry played a decisive role in preserving national identity by maintaining language, traditions, and historical memory across generations. Resistance to imperial control – both passive and violent – demonstrated strong national consciousness. At the same time, segments of the Ukrainian nobility and intelligentsia supported cultural revival through literature, education, and political thought. Influential figures like Taras Shevchenko helped unite social groups around national ideals. Thus, enduring traditions, social cohesion, and cultural activism prevented the empire from fully Russifying Ukrainian society.


This article examines how Russian imperial policy toward Ukraine before 1917 evolved in response to the rise of modern nationalism. Initially, Ukrainian elites were integrated into the empire as part of the “Little Russian” identity, which framed Ukrainians as a branch of a single Russian nation. However, during the 19th century, this traditional loyalty gradually gave way to modern Ukrainian nationalism, especially among the intelligentsia. The Russian government perceived this shift as a political threat and responded with restrictive measures, including censorship and bans on the Ukrainian language. At the same time, social changes such as migration, industrialization, and education contributed to both assimilation and the spread of national consciousness. After the 1905 Revolution, political liberalization allowed Ukrainian organizations, press, and cultural movements to expand, intensifying conflict with Russian nationalism. By the eve of World War I, imperial authorities lacked a coherent policy, oscillating between repression and limited accommodation.


Topic

1.2. History

Next Post

1.2.07.1.